Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Esteri Ayaba's avatar

This is a disappointing take. I expected something more nuanced and contemplated for someone who writes about poetry with such flair. You have not said anything here other than regurgitate Fox News talking points. So abortion is “murder,” but why have those who say so not been campaigning against the death penalty which is still in effect in red states? If they truly believe that, why the obsessive focus on the emotive debate of abortion and not the death penalty? What about the bans on IVF too? Or the abortion done to save lives? They don’t merit a thought? Why reduce the complexity of abortion into a single issue of “murder” as if there is only one kind of abortion? Then you ignored all the one million things the Bible says about giving to the poor to quote a single commandment from the Old Testament out of context. When the same Republicans cut taxes on the rich and redirect them to the poor, which verse in the Bible justifies it? Do you even read the Bible at all? I can go on and on picking your article apart for its many assumptions, but what is the point? As a critic, I would expect you to look beyond what you are told and take on how politicians manipulate people into rage through address these issues inchoately. Instead, all you have said are things I could have read on Brietbart News comments section where people lack nuance in their opinions. Maybe you should research issues before writing about them?

Expand full comment
Isaiah Adepoju's avatar

I started reading Lewis' last night immediately after I read your essay. And I'll be on the lookout for the other books you mentioned. I recognise how culture continually negotiate Christianity— although it ought not be so. And that in the overwhelming growth of a certain culture, Christianity is no more biblically interpreted but interpreted according to the undefined laws of "humanism", and "love", and many other words whose meaning have become so pliant the words themselves have become dead. (Lewis argues along this way on Christianity in the opening pages of his Mere Christianity).

In all, this is a hard truth you've written. But I'm encouraging the completion of the unabridged essay, to further clarify some of the issues raised in the abridged one.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts